The Seattle Police Department declined to comment on the proposed system or its plans for using it, but the debate before the City Council so far has illustrated that there are many opinions about this technology.

Denver renewed its five-year contract with ShotSpotter in 2022. The Denver Police Department said it received nearly 5,000 ShotSpotter alerts in 2023, resulting in 122 arrests and 104 recovered firearms.

Chicago Mayor Brandon Johnson recently announced the city will not renew its contract with ShotSpotter’s gunshot detection company, SoundThinking. The company, based in Fremont, California, says around 150 cities have installed ShotSpotter and the technology has a 97% accuracy rate and a less than 1% rate of identifying false positives.

Justin Ward from DivestSPD, a local activism group advocating for abolishing the police, posed several questions about the value of implementing this technology in Seattle: “What value do we get? What does it do? Does it make us safer? Is it worth that rather large investment?”

Three years after its founding, the Office of Independent Investigations has not moved forward on any of the police killings it has flagged for review.

For ShotSpotter, microphones are spread around an area. When loud sounds that resemble gunfire are detected, they calculate the sound’s location, said Thomas Chittum, senior vice president of forensic services at SoundThinking.

Murgo said Celentano was uninjured in the incident. He added that Andrus declined medical treatment, while a passenger in the Civic sustained minor injuries, was transported to the hospital and not charged.

While ShotSpotter in Denver is not used in tandem with a specific camera system, like the one proposed by Mayor Harrell, Thomas said they sometimes use footage from surveillance and traffic cameras near areas where ShotSpotter is located to determine where shots were fired and take measures to reduce gunfire in those areas.

Alexis Mercedes Rinck was officially sworn in to the Seattle City Council. She sits down to talk collaboration, balance and keeping campaign promises.

ShotSpotter costs $65,000 to $90,000 per square mile per year, along with a $10,000-per-square-mile one-time service fee.

The City Council will be accepting public comment through March 22. Housen said the comment period was extended from the original deadline at the end of February because the topic was gaining a lot of public attention.

Cathy Moore proposed the 2% tax to protect housing and food assistance programs, based on the statewide model 63% of voters opted to keep this election.

“What they should look at instead is the very large number of customers that we do have that do renew, that expand their coverage or that acquire the system because they know that it will help them do a better job of responding to gunfire in their areas,” Chittum said.

He acknowledged there are kinks in the system, with officers sometimes having to respond to false positives like fireworks, garbage disposals or other loud noises, but says officers go through a process to identify if what was heard is gunfire, like a neighborhood survey where people can tell police what they heard or saw.

Murgo said Andrus ended up being caught by state police and taken into custody. He said state police charged Andrus with interfering with an officer, reckless endangerment, engaging police in a pursuit, improper use of a marker plate, reckless driving, operating a motor vehicle without a license, operating a motor vehicle under the influence and numerous other motor vehicle violations.

“One of the mantras of Mayor Harrell that I really love is this idea of One Seattle,” Herbold said. “And I don’t think this is moving forward in that spirit.”

ShotSpotter equipment overlooks the intersection of Chicago’s South Stony Island Avenue and East 63rd Street on Aug. 10, 2021. Chicago won’t renew its contract for the controversial gunshot detection system and will end the use of ShotSpotter technology later this year, Mayor Brandon Johnson’s office announced Tuesday, Feb. 13, 2024. (AP Photo/Charles Rex Arbogast)

Denver Chief of Police Ron Thomas said ShotSpotter has helped officers reach victims quickly and get them treatment, as well as take suspects into custody and recover evidence.

Chicago began its six-year contract with SoundThinking in 2018, and has spent a total of $49 million since placing the technology in largely Black and Latino communities in the south and west parts of the city. Chicago joins several cities that have pulled out of contracts with the gunfire detection company, including Charlotte, North Carolina; Atlanta; New Orleans; Trenton, New Jersey; and San Antonio.

Herbold, who chaired the Council’s Public Safety Committee, opposed ShotSpotter and this kind of technology during her time on the Council.

She said the city should instead prioritize faster police response times or focus on programs like the Seattle Community Safety Initiative, which invests in organizations that focus on disrupting cycles of violence in communities in the Central District as well as West and Southeast Seattle.

Court records show Andrus was held in lieu of a $50,000 bond and was scheduled to appear at state Superior Court in New Haven Oct. 24.

Mayor Harrell has proposed spending $1.8 million on using live audio and video feed of gunshot detection technology and CCTV in high-crime areas in Seattle. (Genna Martin/Crosscut)

Mayor’s office spokesperson Jamie Housen said the technology is only one of the city’s strategies to combat crime. Others include hiring more officers and adding more street lights and sidewalk cleaning.

Company employees filter the sounds to determine if they are gunshots; if they are, alerts are sent to police. Chittum said this allows police to respond sooner to incidents and let communities know law enforcement are doing their jobs.

EAST HAVEN, CT — Newly released footage shows the moment a 39-year-old man struck a town police officer's cruiser then engaged officers in a pursuit last week.

“The fact of the matter is there’s no single thing that can singlehandedly tackle gun crime,” Chittum said. “It really does take a layered approach.”

“I think that Seattle is in a really good position right now where we can learn from all of these cities, what has not worked for them and not waste public funds, trying the same things that we already know have not worked,” said former Seattle City Councilmember Lisa Herbold.

Among the concerns listed by community members at a public forum on the proposal: lack of information on where the technology will be implemented; the companies the city plans to partner with; and lack of outreach to community groups or neighborhoods likely impacted by the plan. They also criticized the brief time they were given to comment.

Thomas said mixed opinions on the technology remain in Denver. Some people feel they are over-surveilled, while others are thankful the technology exists.

“I’m highly concerned that this technology will be solely used to further persecute, harass and mistreat the poor and marginalized in Seattle,” testified Rose King, a University of Washington biochemistry professor. “I don’t believe that we can fight gun violence with police violence.”

Erica Olson said she did not want to invest her tax dollars in ineffective technology that could lead to more biased policing and abuse. “Additionally, I’m interested to know why it was so difficult to find any information on this hearing; with that my trust in the surveillance technology being used responsibly is extremely low,” Olson said. “This meeting was not listed on the Council’s website. It was a huge pain to try to find it.”

Officer Robert Celentano exits his cruiser after it was struck and yells for Andrus to exit his car, the video shows. Andrus is seen reversing the red Honda Civic and speeding off.

Researchers found that in the first months of implementation, false alarms accounted for more than 80% of the detected sounds, and some studies have shown that these numbers do not improve over time.

In the video, Andrus is seen driving recklessly in the Frontage Road parking lot to avoid officers. While trying to escape after an officer attempted to block Andrus, he struck the cruiser.

Overall crime in Seattle decreased by 9% in 2023; however, shootings that year increased 3% over 2022, according to the Seattle Police Department 2023 year-end overview. Homicides have also increased by 23%, but the police force continues to shrink.

Along with the camera and audio systems, the pilot program will include a crime center that responds to real-time alerts.

The state saw an overall increase in crime in 2022, the latest data available from the Washington Association of Sheriffs and Police Chiefs, with record-breaking use of firearms during violent offenses.

An AP investigation revealed flaws in the system after ShotSpotter was used as evidence to prosecute an innocent 65-year-old man for killing a young man in Chicago in 2020.

“There are very infrequent occasions where they get it wrong,” Thomas said. “We have to use the ground truth to notify them [the company] that a false positive came through.”

Areas the city plans to implement this technology include Aurora Avenue North, Downtown in the Third Avenue corridor and in Belltown.

He believes it is a mischaracterization to say that a lot of cities canceled their contracts, when it was only a handful.

Officials in those cities said they stopped using the system because it consistently misidentified fireworks or motorcycle sounds as gunshots. Chicago’s inspector general said in a report that police responding to ShotSpotter alerts rarely found evidence of a gun-related crime.

The Jumpstart tax was originally intended to raise funds for housing and climate projects. Now the door is open for the city to spend it freely.

Celentano reports over his radio that the suspect hit him, and follows the Civic out of the parking lot and onto Interstate 95 north with his siren on.

Researchers said the annual cost of gun violence to the U.S. economy is around $229 million. ShotSpotter’s fees for large cities like Chicago and New York range from $3.9 to $5.4 million a year. The study concluded the technology is only adding to the cost of gun violence in the nation, instead of reducing it.

Robert Andrus of New Haven previously failed to stop for another officer at around 10 p.m. Oct. 2, according to East Haven police Capt. Joseph Murgo. Murgo said Andrus then was spotted in a parking lot and officers arrived to try to stop him, less than 30 minutes after the initial incident.

The alerts did increase the workload of police going to places where no evidence of a shooting had occurred, according to the report.

The crime prevention technology, which pulls live audio and video feeds, has been backed by Mayor Harrell even as other cities report mixed results.

“Unlike public policies that take time and political will to implement, ShotSpotter is available for purchase, and its implementation is dictated by a municipality’s willingness to pay,” the researchers wrote.

The ACLU Washington state chapter echoed many of the community comments opposing the proposal. “It ends up draining city and police resources rather than actually helping with community safety,” said Tee Sannon, ACLU Washington technology policy program director.

“Best-case scenario is that it helps them [police] respond quicker to shots fired, and that is going to result in more arrests? Is that necessarily what most benefits the community? I think the ideal outcome is to not have people shot at all,” Ward said.

The Washington State Institute for Public Policy has kept track of the costs and benefits of public policy programs since the 1990s, and a 2015 review of the research found crime prevention programs at the youth and adult level to be more effective than using technology like CCTV to reduce crime.

A study from the Journal of Experimental Criminology looked at the efficacy of pairing a camera system with a different gunshot detector technology, like the system Seattle is proposing, in high-crime areas in Philadelphia, and found a 259% increase in reported gunshots but no increase in confirmed shootings.

Various independent studies have shown the technology fails to accomplish its objective. A study from 1999 to 2016 across 68 large U.S. metropolitan counties said ShotSpotter had no significant impact on firearm-related homicides or arrest outcomes.

Seattle Mayor Bruce Harrell has pushed for two years to adopt a gunfire detection system that he believes would deter criminal activity. The City Council is still taking public comment period on the idea, but opponents, like some community groups and national experts, have already weighed in, calling the technology costly and ineffective and saying the money would be better spent on other resources to prevent and end gun violence.

Instead, the report said using cameras in high-crime areas merely increased the chances that offenders would plead guilty after a crime occurred, instead of preventing it from happening. While this data has been available for decades, the study said its cost-benefit analysis is underused in the study of crime prevention.

The Council is considering spending $1.8 million on a pilot project proposed by the Seattle Police Department to try a gunfire detection system with both audio and live video monitoring.

While ShotSpotter is one of the better-known companies, Housen said the city has not named the company’s acoustic gunshot locator system as its partner.

Chittum said using ShotSpotter with a proposed camera system is an effective strategy to end gun violence and build strong connections with the community.

Ward pointed out that although the pilot programs are intended to prevent crimes, technology systems respond only after a crime has occurred.

The Mayor’s office released a statement to Crosscut saying that the police staffing shortage, increase in homicides and use of firearms in these cases is why it wants to try this crime prevention technology.

“People think of me as being a champion of civil rights and I am, but with my criticism of this technology, I’m intentionally taking off my civil liberties hat and putting on a hat that is about focusing our resources on public safety issues in a strategic way that makes good sense and use of limited resources,” Herbold said.

“The best you could do is take a few people off the street, but you’re not going to actually take them and transform their lives and put them on a path where they’re going to be a productive member of society,” Ward added.

In 2012 the Philadelphia Police Department established a real-time crime center, where staff receive 911 calls and can look at live monitoring cameras of an area to see when a crime is occuring, or capture evidence after it has occurred.